Perhaps a strange opinion, but itās my favourite Lennon album and very nearly my favourite Yoko album - her song Your Hands is such a powerful evocation of grief, for me standing next to Here Today in its use of music to communicate the loss of someone so incredible (of course, both songs from the two people who knew and loved John the most).
Perhaps the context changes my perspective, but this album is not just one released after Johnās death but is one definitively posthumous in all of the tragedy that conveys - Grow Old With Me can only work here as its unfinished demo, next to Yokoās wonderful Let Me Count the Ways, so Iām happy the ācompleteā treatment was left until later, including on the Gimme Some Truth compilation. Yoko and Sean have never tried to make the story of John just that he died - he was killed, far too young, by a violent act. Leaving GOWM as it is shows Lennon is someone who was reaching a new creative peak before it was all taken away.
The concept of the dialogue - between a man looking forward to a new lifeās beginning and his now widow who knows that the story ended far too soon - I feel is even stronger here than on Double Fantasy, where it already works very well.
Ultimately, the album contains really brilliant songs all the way through, and Iām very happy thereās very well mixed versions of the most complete studio takes of the Lennon songs - it would have been too jarring, and too artificial given he did these studio recordings, to segue from all demos for John into polished studio songs from Yoko. It works very well for the final piece of dialogue.
I love John and Yoko in 1980, if thatās not obvious! Iām very much looking forward to if thereās any kind of remaster/boxset/Ultimate version of DF and M&H. I really hope we get one of the brilliant tie-in books for the albums!